Blog

What a Local SEO Audit Should Include (and What to Ignore)

By Sandstone Search ·

A useful local SEO audit checks five things: your Google Business Profile, your website's titles and pages, technical basics like indexing and mobile speed, your name, address and phone across directories, and what AI tools say about you. It should end with a short fix list ranked by impact, not a 60-page PDF.

If you run a plumbing, HVAC, pool or roofing business in St. George, Washington or Hurricane, here's what a real audit looks like, and what you can safely ignore.

1. Your Google Business Profile

For a lot of "near me" searches, your profile shows up before your website does. Google's own help page says local results are based mainly on relevance, distance and prominence, and that businesses with complete, accurate information are more likely to show up. An audit should check:

  • Is the profile verified, and do you (not a former employee or agency) own it?
  • Is the primary category the most specific one that fits your main service?
  • Are services, hours, service areas and the description complete?
  • If you work at customers' homes, is it set up as a service-area business with the address hidden?
  • Are reviews being answered? Are there real photos of your work?

2. Your website's titles and pages

  • Does the homepage title say what you do and where, for example "Water Heater Repair in St. George, UT", instead of "Home"?
  • Is there one clear page for each main service, and for each town you really serve?
  • Do those pages answer the questions customers ask, like price ranges, service areas and response times, in plain words?
  • Do your phone number and service area appear as text, not only inside an image?

3. Technical basics

  • Is the site indexed? Search Google for site:yourdomain.com. If almost nothing shows, that comes first.
  • Is there a sitemap, and does robots.txt allow search engines (and AI search crawlers) in?
  • Does it load quickly and read well on a phone?
  • Is there schema (structured data) describing your business, and does it match what's visible on the page?

4. Name, address and phone (NAP) across directories

Check that your Google profile, website, Yelp, BBB, Apple Maps, Bing, Facebook and your local chamber listing all show the same business name, phone number and (if you show one) address. Old phone numbers and old addresses from a move are the most common problems we see in Washington County. One example: Apple Valley addresses use Hurricane's 84737 ZIP code, so listings for the same business can show either town.

5. What AI tools say about you

Ask an AI assistant "who's the best [your service] in [your town]?" and note who it names and which websites it cites. Answers change from day to day, so treat one check as a snapshot, not a ranking. The sites it cites are usually the directories worth cleaning up first.

What to ignore

  • "SEO scores" and "domain authority" as goals. Google says third-party tools don't have access to its internal ranking data. Use them to find problems, not to measure success.
  • Submitting your site to hundreds of directories. Google's guide to hiring an SEO calls this kind of thing a typically useless exercise. A dozen accurate, relevant listings beat 300 junk ones.
  • Keyword density. Write for the customer. Say the service and the town naturally, once or twice, where it makes sense.
  • Anyone guaranteeing a #1 ranking. Google says plainly that no one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.

What you should get at the end

A short list: the 3 to 5 changes that matter most, why each one matters, and who will do it. You should be able to check every item yourself.

Want that list for your business? Request a free AI search snapshot. It's a one-page version of this audit, sent by email.

Sources

Related pages

Quick answers

What should a local SEO audit include?

Five areas: your Google Business Profile, your website's titles and service and town pages, technical basics like indexing and mobile speed, whether your name, address and phone match across directories, and what AI tools say when asked for your service in your town. It should end with a short, ranked fix list.

Should I give an SEO company access to my Google accounts for an audit?

For an audit, read access is enough. Google's own advice is to grant only read access to Search Console at the audit stage, not write access. Never hand over your password.

Is a high third-party 'SEO score' what matters?

No. Google says third-party SEO tools don't have access to its internal ranking data. Scores can point to problems worth checking, but they aren't rankings and they aren't customers.

See what Google and AI tools say about your business

Free, one-page AI search snapshot. No cost, no obligation. Delivered by email.

Get your free AI search snapshotSee plans